Networking/Computing Tips/Tricks

archive Traceroute Comparison Capture pcapng for Wireshark (15 KB)

Equal-Cost Multi-Path (ECMP) is a forwarding mechanism for routing packets along multiple paths of equal cost with the goal to achieve almost equally distributed link load sharing. This, of course, significantly impacts a router's next-hop (path) decision.

For further details, look at RFC 2991, "Multipath Issues in Unicast and Multicast Next-Hop Selection," and RFC 2992, "Analysis of an Equal-Cost Multi-Path Algorithm."

How can we see this?  Normal Traceroute expects the network to do traditional routing, where all your traffic follows the same path unless there is a failure in the network to trigger a routing table update.  Chances of this are extremely small in the real world.

So how can we detect if ECMP is in play in the network your traffic is traversing?  The answer is we need a special version of Traceroute that can figure out if ECMP is in play.

There are two solutions: Paris Traceroute and Dublin Traceroute.  

The initial version of traceroute was implemented by Van Jacobson from a suggestion by Steve Deering.

Paris traceroute was implemented by Xavier Cuvellier. Debugged and enhanced by Brice Augustin.  The current version is available at: http://www.paris-traceroute.net

Dublin Traceroute was built on top of Paris Traceroute and is written by Andrea Barberio from, you guessed it, Dublin.  You can find Dublin Traceroute at https://dublin-traceroute.net/README.md

What is the difference?  Dublin Traceroute uses the techniques invented by the authors of Paris-traceroute to enumerate the paths of ECMP flow-based load balancing, but introduces a new technique for NAT detection.

Lets look at Paris Traceroute first.

To check and see if you have this: simply type:

paris-traceroute

Screenshot from 2018 10 24 11 27 42

I did not have it, so I followed the instructions to install it on my Ubuntu Linux box.

sudo apt install paris-traceroute

Once done, I now get the proper response:

Screenshot from 2018 10 24 11 32 00

All is good.  You can use the following command to see what all the command line options are:

paris-traceroute -h

Now let's see if we have Dublin Traceroute installed:

dublin-traceroute

Screenshot from 2018 10 24 14 17 12

Install it with:

sudo apt-get install dublin-traceroute

To get the help type:

dublin-traceroute --help

Great!

Let's run them both to see what happens when we traceroute to Google's public DNS at 8.8.8.8.  First, here is a normal, regular traceroute:

Screenshot from 2018 10 24 14 32 52

Now, let's use Paris Traceroute:

Screenshot from 2018 10 24 14 36 31

Now Dublin Traceroute (you will note I add the '-n 3' parameter as this limits Dublin Traceroute to 3 probes which is the same as the Paris Traceroute default):

Screenshot from 2018 10 24 14 43 31 

Very different. 

To be fair, I am doing this from behing my home router which is a NAT.  So Dublin is successful as advertised in seeing there is some ECMP going on.  Look at the 8th hop.  We see there are two dirrent IP addresses, and we see them toggling.  Same thing in the 12th hop.

If you want to dig a bit deeper, I have also enclosed a Wireshark packet capture of the three traceroutes for your parusal and deeper dissection.

So cool!  I hope, like me, this is the last time you ever use regular traceroute!

Happy Tracerouting!!

Comments powered by CComment

Find by Tag

4G Networks 5G Networks 6LoWLAN 6LoWPAN 802.11 802.11ah 802.11ax 802.11ay 802.11az Ad-Hoc Addressing Analysis Ansible Architecture ARP Assessment AToM Automation Baseline BGP Bloom's Taxonomy Bluehost Cable cat CellStream Cellular Central Office Cheat Sheet Chrome Cisco Cloud CMD Company Policy Computer Consulting Data Center Data Networking Dependencies DHCPv6 DNS Docker Documentation Dublin-Traceroute dumpcap Earth Earthquakes ECMP Ethernet Ethics Etiquette Evaluation Field Operations Five Monkey Rule G-MPLS Gauge GeoIP GNS3 Google GQUIC Hands-On History Home Network ICMP ICMPv6 IEEE 802.11p IEEE 802.15.4 India Internet IoT IPv4 IPv6 IRINN IS-IS L2VPN L3VPN LDP LifeNet Linux LLN LoL M-BGP MAC Macro Microsoft Milky Way mininet Monitoring MPLS mtr Multicast Murphy Name Resolution Netcat NetMon netsh Networking nmap NSE Observations OLPC Online School OpenFlow OSPF OSPFv2 OSPFv3 OSX OTT Paris-Traceroute Parrot PIM Policy POTS POTS to Pipes PPP Profile Project Management PW3E QoS QUIC Railroad Remote Desktop Requirements Resume Review RIP Routing RPL RSVP Rural SDN Security Service Provider Small Business SONET Speed SSL Status Storms Subnetting Support SYSCTL T-Shark TCP TCP/IP Telco Telecom 101 Telecommunications Telephone Testing Tools Traceroute Traffic Engineering Training Travel Tunnel Ubuntu Utility Video Virtualbox Virtualization VoIP VRF VXLAN Wi-Fi Wi-Fi 4 Wi-Fi 5 Wi-Fi 6 Windows Wireless Wireless 5G Wireshark WLAN Writing Zenmap ZigBee

Twitter Feed